Arumi Madana Hafwa Hafwa, Azmi Afifatun Nafi’ah Nafi'ah, Sandy Teguh Arie

Blended learning research in Indonesia (2018–2023): A bibliometric analysis of trends, challenges, and opportunities

Introduction

Blended learning research in indonesia (2018–2023): a bibliometric analysis of trends, challenges, and opportunities. Bibliometric analysis of blended learning research in Indonesia (2018-2023). Uncover trends, COVID-19 impact, challenges (digital infrastructure, educator preparedness), and opportunities.

Abstract

The bibliometric analysis of blended learning research in Indonesia from 2018 to 2023 reveals a transformative landscape influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic. This study examines scientific production, thematic evolution, and research dynamics surrounding blended learning, utilizing advanced bibliometric techniques and visualization tools. The findings indicate a significant surge in publications during 2020–2021, reflecting the educational sector's rapid adaptation to unprecedented disruptions. Through comprehensive keyword network analysis and citation patterns, the study uncovers multidimensional perspectives on blended learning, emphasizing technological integration, pedagogical innovation, and socio-cultural considerations. The research highlights a complex interplay between technological advancements, educational methodologies, and systemic challenges. Furthermore, the study spans multiple disciplines, including social sciences, physics, computer science, and engineering, demonstrating the interdisciplinary nature of blended learning implementation. Despite remarkable progress, critical barriers persist, including limitations in digital infrastructure, unequal technological access, and inadequate educator preparedness. These challenges underscore the need for strategic interventions to enhance the effectiveness of blended learning. By providing nuanced insights into Indonesia’s evolving educational landscape, this analysis highlights both opportunities and obstacles in implementing blended learning strategies across diverse educational contexts.

Review

This bibliometric analysis of blended learning research in Indonesia from 2018 to 2023 presents a timely and highly relevant contribution to the educational literature, particularly in understanding the transformative impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on pedagogical practices in the region. The study's objective to examine scientific production, thematic evolution, and research dynamics using advanced bibliometric techniques is well-articulated. The abstract effectively highlights the significant surge in publications during 2020–2021, underscoring the rapid adaptation within Indonesia's educational sector. The interdisciplinary scope, encompassing social sciences, physics, computer science, and engineering, is a compelling finding, demonstrating the pervasive influence and implementation of blended learning across diverse academic fields. The findings presented indicate a robust and multidimensional exploration of blended learning, moving beyond mere technological adoption to include pedagogical innovation and crucial socio-cultural considerations. The analysis, through keyword network analysis and citation patterns, appears to have successfully uncovered the complex interplay between technological advancements, educational methodologies, and systemic challenges specific to the Indonesian context. This depth of insight is crucial for understanding how blended learning is not merely a technical solution but a deeply embedded educational strategy shaped by diverse factors. The study effectively leverages its chosen methodology to illuminate research trends and thematic shifts that are invaluable for charting the evolution of blended learning in a critical period. However, the abstract also clearly identifies persistent and critical barriers to effective blended learning implementation, including limitations in digital infrastructure, unequal technological access, and inadequate educator preparedness. These challenges are not unique to Indonesia but are acutely felt in developing contexts, making the strategic interventions suggested by the study particularly significant. By pinpointing these obstacles, the research not only provides a retrospective view of trends but also offers forward-looking insights into necessary policy and practical adjustments. The overall value of this analysis lies in its nuanced portrayal of both the opportunities stemming from technological and pedagogical advancements, and the formidable obstacles that must be addressed to foster equitable and effective blended learning strategies across diverse Indonesian educational settings.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.