Joan Daw

Catholic Church Engagement in Australian Society: A Symbiotic Relationship between "The Religious" and "The Secular"?

Introduction

Catholic church engagement in australian society: a symbiotic relationship between "the religious" and "the secular"?. Examine the Catholic Church's engagement in Australian society via social welfare services. Data from surveys reveal how religious and secular orientations create a symbiotic relationship.

Abstract

The Catholic Church is a major provider of social welfare services in Australian society. Attitudes and practices relating to charitable/welfare activity are, therefore, important indicators of the Church 's engagement in pluralist society. In this paper, data from the 1996 Australian Catholic Church Life Survey, the 2001 National Church Life Survey (Catholic Component), and the 1998 Australian Community Survey are used to examine such indicators. The research shows that charity/welfare is regarded by Catholics as a core function of religion. Moreover, this is shown to tap into two differing orientations: one specifically religious, the other less so. These two orientations are also identified in the provision of welfare services by Catholic organisations in the sense that their mission accords with the first orientation, while service delivery tends to accord with the second. These findings prompt exploration of the possibility of a symbiotic relationship between "the religious" and "the secular" in Catholicism's social engagement.

Review

This paper investigates the multifaceted engagement of the Catholic Church in Australian society, particularly through its substantial role as a provider of social welfare services. The authors use data from several key Australian surveys (1996 Australian Catholic Church Life Survey, 2001 National Church Life Survey - Catholic Component, and 1998 Australian Community Survey) to examine attitudes and practices related to charitable activity. The central proposition, as highlighted by the title, explores the potential for a "symbiotic relationship" between "the religious" and "the secular" within this engagement, offering a compelling framework for understanding the Church's role in a pluralist context. A significant strength of the research lies in its empirical foundation, leveraging established and comprehensive survey data to dissect the nuances of Catholic engagement. The findings are particularly insightful, demonstrating that charity and welfare are not merely peripheral activities but are considered a core function of religion by Catholics. Crucially, the paper identifies two distinct orientations underpinning this engagement: one overtly religious and another seemingly less so. This differentiation is further extended to the operational level of Catholic welfare organizations, where mission statements often align with the religious orientation, while actual service delivery leans towards the less overtly religious. This distinction provides a valuable conceptual tool for analyzing the complex interplay between faith-driven purpose and practical, secular-facing service provision. While the abstract effectively outlines a robust analytical framework, the full paper would benefit from a more explicit theoretical unpacking of what constitutes "the religious" and "the secular" in this specific context, especially concerning the "less so" orientation. Further exploration of the *mechanisms* through which this proposed "symbiotic relationship" operates would also be invaluable, moving beyond identification to explaining its dynamics and implications for both the Church and Australian society. Given the age of the primary data (1996-2001), it would be beneficial for the paper to briefly contextualize these findings within contemporary social and religious shifts, perhaps highlighting how these foundational insights continue to resonate or have evolved. This research offers a strong basis for understanding the Catholic Church's historical and ongoing social contribution, providing a critical lens for future studies on faith-based organizations in diverse societies.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.