Proceedings

Published IBIC'17 proceedings

Introduction

Published ibic'17 proceedings. Explore the published proceedings of IBIC'17 (International Beam Instrumentation Conference), featuring key research papers and insights from 2017.

Abstract

Review

This submission, titled "Published IBIC'17 proceedings," is highly problematic due to the complete absence of an abstract. The title itself suggests an announcement or a reference to a published collection of papers from the IBIC'17 conference. However, without any accompanying abstract, it is impossible to ascertain the nature, scope, purpose, or contribution of this specific submission. An abstract is fundamental to any scholarly work, providing a concise summary of its content, methodology, results, and conclusions, allowing reviewers and readers to quickly grasp its essence. The primary and overriding issue is the missing abstract. This omission renders the submission unreviewable from an academic standpoint, as there is no content to evaluate. It is unclear whether this submission is intended as an announcement *of* the proceedings, an editorial introduction *to* the proceedings, a meta-analysis *of* the proceedings, or perhaps even the proceedings themselves submitted in an unconventional format. Without an abstract, the relevance, novelty, and significance of this contribution cannot be assessed, nor can its target audience or suitability for the journal be determined. Therefore, this submission cannot be accepted in its current form. A major revision is absolutely necessary. The authors must provide a comprehensive abstract that clearly articulates the purpose and content of this submission. If it is an announcement, it should summarize what the proceedings cover; if an introduction, what themes it discusses; if a meta-paper, what analysis it presents. Furthermore, the authors should clarify what specific document or work this submission represents, ensuring it aligns with the typical format and expectations for scholarly journal publications.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.