Laura Oulanne, Anna Tomi

Lähelle ja kauas

Introduction

Lähelle ja kauas. Tutki läheisyyden ja etäisyyden filosofisia käsitteitä. Pohdi niiden vaikutuksia ihmiseen ja yhteiskuntaan laajasti.

Abstract

Review

The title "Lähelle ja kauas" is intriguing and highly evocative, suggesting a thematic exploration of proximity, distance, perspective, or scope, potentially across various disciplines such as philosophy, sociology, geography, or even physics. However, the complete absence of an abstract makes it impossible to provide any meaningful assessment of the paper's content, aims, or methodology. An abstract is the foundational component of any academic submission, designed to concisely inform reviewers and readers about the article's core arguments, research questions, theoretical framework, methods, key findings, and overall contribution to the field. Without this essential summary, the paper's very essence remains undefined. Consequently, the critical aspects typically evaluated in a peer review, such as the originality of the research, the rigor of its methodology, the clarity and coherence of its argumentation, the significance of its conclusions, or its relevance to the journal's scope, cannot be addressed. The ambiguity of the title, while poetic, necessitates an abstract to ground it within a specific academic context and disciplinary discourse. It is currently unclear what specific phenomena are being examined "near and far," what theoretical lens is applied, what empirical data (if any) is presented, or what new insights are being offered. This lack of information precludes any assessment of the paper's academic merit or potential impact. In light of these fundamental omissions, a substantive review of this submission is simply not feasible at this stage. I strongly recommend that the author provides a comprehensive and informative abstract that clearly outlines the paper's objectives, theoretical framework, research questions, methodologies employed, principal findings, and their broader implications. Once such an abstract is submitted, along with the full manuscript, the paper can then be properly evaluated against the established criteria for academic publication. Until then, the submission remains incomplete and unreviewable.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.