Ruth V. Lewin-Broit

Prescribing Messiah: A Case Study concerning Internal Conversion

Introduction

Prescribing messiah: a case study concerning internal conversion. Analyze Maimonides' 1172 Iggeret Ternan epistle, focusing on internal conversion in medieval Jewish communities under Islam. Explores social & religious history and power changes.

Abstract

This paper aims to analyse certain issues in the social and religious history of medieval Jewish communities under the rule of Islam. Its focus is an epistle which was sent by Maimonides in 1172 in response to an appeal from a Yemenite rabbi, Jacob al-Fayumi. The letter, commonly known as Iggeret Ternan, deals with no less than six inter-related topics ranging from family traditions to binding rabbinical instructions. Written at the time of the crusades, the Iggeret reveals the anxious responses of marginal communities to the changes in the quality and structure of power in the Middle Eastern region.

Review

This paper proposes an intriguing case study rooted in the social and religious history of medieval Jewish communities under Islamic rule, centering on Maimonides's significant 1172 epistle, *Iggeret Teiman*. The abstract effectively highlights the richness of this primary source, noting its exploration of six interrelated topics, from communal traditions to rabbinical authority, all set against the tumultuous backdrop of the Crusades and shifting regional power dynamics. The paper's aim to reveal the "anxious responses of marginal communities" promises a valuable contribution to our understanding of resilience and adaptation in times of profound crisis, making the choice of Maimonides's authoritative intervention particularly salient. The greatest strength of this proposed work lies in its focus on *Iggeret Teiman*, a seminal document offering unparalleled insight into Maimonides's thought, medieval Jewish life, and the complex interplay of messianic fervor, persecution, and intellectual leadership. By analyzing this letter, the paper is poised to illuminate how Maimonides, through his "prescription," sought to guide a vulnerable community facing existential threats, potentially reframing their spiritual and social outlook. The abstract's emphasis on the "changes in the quality and structure of power" provides a crucial lens through which to examine the *Iggeret*'s contents, suggesting a nuanced exploration of both internal communal dynamics and external socio-political pressures, thereby enriching our understanding of medieval Jewish historiography. While the abstract sets a compelling stage, further clarification on the specific analytical frameworks suggested by the title, "Prescribing Messiah" and "Internal Conversion," would strengthen the paper's core argument. The term "Internal Conversion" in particular requires explicit definition within the context of Maimonides's epistle; does it refer to an ideological shift within the community, a spiritual reorientation away from false messianism, or perhaps a process of intellectual conversion to Maimonides's rationalist worldview? Clearly articulating how these concepts will be operationalized across the *Iggeret Teiman*'s varied topics will ensure the paper delivers on the conceptual depth implied by its title, moving beyond a historical analysis to offer a distinct and impactful scholarly contribution.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.