Fiona Murphy

Fatigue markers

Introduction

Fatigue markers. Read 'Fatigue markers,' a captivating new short story. Dive into a unique narrative exploring the subtle signs and impacts of exhaustion.

Abstract

A new short story.

Review

The submission presents a significant incongruity between its title and abstract, which immediately raises concerns about its suitability for a scientific journal. The title, "Fatigue markers," strongly suggests a research paper likely focused on biological, physiological, or psychological indicators of fatigue within a medical, exercise science, or health context. However, the accompanying abstract explicitly states, "A new short story," indicating that the content is creative fiction rather than scientific research. This fundamental mismatch makes it impossible to conduct a meaningful peer review from a scientific perspective. As a reviewer, I cannot assess the methodology, research questions, data analysis, experimental design, or the contribution to existing scientific literature, as the submission purports to be a narrative work. There is no information provided about the plot, characters, themes, or literary style of the "short story," nor is there any explanation of how such a creative piece might relate to, or justify its inclusion in, a scientific journal focused on fatigue. Given the contradictory nature of the title and abstract, it is evident that this submission cannot be evaluated as a scientific article. It appears to be either a miscategorized submission, a mistake in the submission process, or content intended for a different publication venue (e.g., a literary journal). I strongly recommend immediate rejection for any scientific journal. The author should be contacted to clarify the true nature of their submission and be advised to provide a proper scientific abstract if the title "Fatigue markers" reflects the actual content, or to submit their short story to an appropriate literary outlet if that is its true form.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.