Anna Kérchy

Előszó

Introduction

Előszó. Olvasd el az Előszót, amely bevezetőt nyújt egy műhöz, feltárja annak célját és áttekintést ad a várható tartalomról.

Abstract

Review

The submission, titled "Előszó," presents a unique challenge for review as it lacks any accompanying abstract or body text for evaluation. "Előszó" translates to "Foreword" or "Preface," which strongly suggests that this document, in its current form, is intended as an introductory piece rather than a self-contained research paper. Without an abstract, it is impossible to glean any information regarding the paper's scope, objectives, methodology, findings, or potential contributions to the field. This fundamental absence prevents any initial assessment of its relevance, novelty, or suitability for publication in a scientific journal. As an expert reviewer, my primary task is to assess the scientific merit, methodological rigor, clarity of presentation, and potential impact of a manuscript. However, given only a title and an empty abstract, none of these critical aspects can be addressed. There is no research question to identify, no methods to scrutinize, no data to evaluate, and no conclusions to weigh. Consequently, it is impossible to comment on the quality of the research, the validity of any claims, or the significance of any results, as no such content has been provided for review. In conclusion, while the title "Előszó" clearly indicates an introductory function, a scientific journal submission requires a substantive abstract that summarizes the core content of the research. Without this, and indeed without any accompanying body of work, the submission as presented falls significantly short of the requirements for a peer-reviewed article. For this to be considered further, a comprehensive abstract detailing the research content, along with the full manuscript, would be absolutely essential to facilitate any meaningful review process.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.