Oscarino da Silva Ivo

Da correspondência de verbos em dental com nomes em sibilante

Introduction

Da correspondência de verbos em dental com nomes em sibilante. Explore as dificuldades na grafia do português, como a variação do som 'sê' (/s/, /ss/, /c/, /ç/, /x/). Entenda a correspondência de verbos em dental e nomes sibilantes.

Abstract

A grafia considerada correta de certos tipos de palavras em português acarreta algumas dificuldades que muitas pessoas menos avisadas consideram perturbadoras principalmente para os que se iniciam na arte de escrever, ou que não puderam receber uma carga maior de informações. Por essa razão, vemos que muitos se insurgem contra as nossas regras ortográficas e propugnam por uma simplificação cada vez maior da nossa escrita. Uma dessas chamadas dificuldades é a diferença de grafia do som sê, ora com /s/, ora com /ss/, ora com ,/c/, ora com /ç/, ora com /x/.

Review

The submission presents a title, "Da correspondência de verbos em dental com nomes em sibilante," that suggests a highly specialized linguistic analysis of specific phonological or morphological correspondences in Portuguese. However, the accompanying abstract falls significantly short of outlining the actual content, scope, or methodology of such a paper. It opens with a broad discussion on general orthographic difficulties in Portuguese and advocates for simplification, a common and relevant topic, but one that appears incongruous with the specificity implied by the title. This immediate disconnect between the proposed focus and the descriptive abstract raises concerns about the paper's clarity and precise contribution to the field. The abstract's primary weakness lies in its complete omission of key components expected in a scholarly summary. There is no mention of the paper's specific objectives, research questions, theoretical framework, methodology (e.g., corpus analysis, historical linguistics, phonological study), or anticipated findings. Instead, it offers a general observation about the multiple spellings of the 'sê' sound, which, while a genuine orthographic challenge, does not explicitly connect to the "correspondence of dental verbs with sibilant nouns" as indicated by the title. This lack of detail makes it impossible to ascertain what unique insights or analyses the paper provides, or how it addresses the highly specific linguistic phenomenon suggested by its title. It reads more like an introductory paragraph to a general essay on orthography reform than a concise summary of a focused research paper. Given these fundamental deficiencies, the paper in its current conceptualization (as presented by the title and abstract) cannot be adequately reviewed or considered for publication. Substantial revisions are required, beginning with a complete overhaul of the abstract. The abstract must clearly and concisely articulate the paper's specific research question(s), its methodology, the linguistic data analyzed, the main arguments or findings, and their significance. Crucially, the abstract must align directly with the specific focus promised by the title, explicitly demonstrating how the paper contributes to understanding the correspondence between dental verbs and sibilant nouns. Without these critical elements, the paper's scholarly value remains entirely unclear.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.