Rubens dos Santos

A sétima sinfonia de Píndaro

Introduction

A sétima sinfonia de píndaro. Explore a conexão entre heróis homéricos e campeões de Píndaro no contexto da paidéia. Entenda o ideal de excelência grega e "kalokagathia" na Grécia Antiga.

Abstract

Da gesta dos heróis homéricos à rumorosa celebração dos campeões de Píndaro é muito pequena a diferença de significado quando situamos os fatos no contexto da "paidéia". A fúria de Aquiles ceifando cabeças troianas não é maior exemplo da inefável "kalekagatheia" que a dextreza, elasticidade ou resistência do bem louvado Diágoras, o supercampeão olímpico. Se distanciamento houve no tempo, em ambos os casos a meta era "o apogeu do divino na forma humana". E se os tempos mudaram foi para ensejar a todos, até à Arcádia e à Tessália, rudes e broncas, a honra de celebrar seus campeões, tão diferentes embora do belo ideal da nobreza arcaica.

Review

This abstract presents a compelling and thought-provoking analysis comparing the ideals embodied by Homeric heroes and Pindaric champions within the framework of ancient Greek *paideia*. The core argument posits a profound continuity in meaning between the "fury of Achilles" and the "dexterity, elasticity, or resistance" of Pindar's acclaimed athletes, both serving as exemplars of *kalokagathia* and the pursuit of "the apogee of the divine in human form." By situating these figures within a broader cultural and educational context, the author proposes a valuable re-evaluation of how heroic ideals persisted and evolved across different historical periods in ancient Greece. A key strength of the abstract lies in its clear articulation of the central thesis and the sophisticated conceptual tools—*paideia* and *kalokagathia*—it employs to bridge the gap between seemingly disparate heroic traditions. The notion that "the times changed... to allow everyone, even to Arcadia and Thessaly, rude and rough, the honor of celebrating their champions" is particularly intriguing, hinting at a democratization or broadening of the heroic ideal beyond the archaic nobility. However, while the abstract emphasizes continuity, it also briefly alludes to "distanciamento no tempo" and champions "tão diferentes embora do belo ideal da nobreza arcaica." The full paper would benefit immensely from a deeper exploration of these nuanced differences and the precise nature of this evolution, rather than just the underlying unity. Furthermore, the abstract does not clarify the intriguing and highly metaphorical title, "A sétima sinfonia de Píndaro," leaving a significant conceptual gap for the reader. Overall, the abstract suggests a potentially significant contribution to the study of classical Greek literature and culture, offering a fresh perspective on the enduring power of heroic ideals. To fully realize its promise, the complete work should meticulously unpack the metaphorical implications of its title, provide robust textual evidence to support its claims regarding both Homer and Pindar, and thoroughly explore the complexities of continuity and divergence in the representation of *kalokagathia* across the periods discussed. Addressing these points will undoubtedly solidify the paper's scholarly impact and enrich its sophisticated analytical framework.

Full Text

Comments

You need to be logged in to post a comment.